When Your Digital Footprint Becomes Legal Evidence

Main Takeaway

India’s legal and regulatory landscape has undergone a tectonic shift with the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 (DPDP Act), the Information Technology Act, 2000, and the triad of new codes—the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA), Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), and Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS). Everyday digital interactions—emails, WhatsApp chats, server logs, even AI-generated outputs—can now become determinative legal evidence. The stakes for compliance, audit readiness, and digital data governance have never been higher, not just for legal practitioners but for business leaders, entrepreneurs, and startups.

Introduction: The Era of Digital Footprints and Legal Evidence

Not long ago, business disputes and criminal prosecutions relied on hard-copy documents and in-person testimony. Today, the digital revolution—and a wave of new statutes—means that your entire corporate memory, from casual chats to encrypted server logs, may be summoned to court or a regulator. The critical question is not if your digital footprint will be scrutinized, but how prepared you are for it to stand up as admissible, decisive evidence.

This blog unpacks how the DPDP Act 2023, IT Act 2000, Income Tax Act, Companies Act, MSMED Act, EU AI Act, and the new codes (BSA, BNSS, BNS) collectively transform the evidentiary value and procedures around digital data for Indian businesses.

Acts Discussed in Detail

- Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 (**DPDP Act**) 

- Information Technology Act, 2000 (**IT Act**)

- Income Tax Act (Sections on search, seizure, and digital data)

- Companies Act, 2013

- Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 (**MSMED Act**)

- EU AI Act (Regulation (EU) 2024/1689)

- Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (**BSA/Evidence Act**)

- Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (**BNSS**)

- Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (**BNS**)

A.  The Shift from Paper to Pixels: IT Act and Admissibility

Information Technology Act, 2000

• Section 2(t) "Electronic record": Expansively includes any record, data, image, sound stored or transmitted electronically.

• Section 4: Grants legal equivalency to electronic records and paper records, thereby making emails, files, and digital contracts legally valid.

• Section 7: Recognises retention of electronic records for “subsequent reference.”

B. Indian Evidence Act (now Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023)

- Section 65B (under the old act): Introduced the now-standard requirement for electronic evidence: for digital documents to be admissible, a special certificate under S. 65B(4) must be produced, stating facts about the device and process.

- This idea has now been significantly updated and expanded under the BSA under S. 63(4)

C. DPDP Act 2023: Data Privacy, Consent, and Legal Risk

### Key Provisions Impacting Legal Evidence

- Consent & Notice (§5–6): Data fiduciaries (businesses) must obtain unambiguous, purpose-specific consent, and keep detailed, retrievable records of such consent.

- Breach Notification (§8): Mandates prompt notification to authorities and affected parties in the event of a personal data breach—becoming formal evidence in regulatory proceedings.

- Data Retention & Erasure (§8): After purpose completion or withdrawal of consent, data (including logs, records, consents) must be securely erased unless law requires further retention.

- Significant Data Fiduciaries (§9): Higher bar for compliance—requiring Data Protection Officers, mandatory audits, and Data Protection Impact Assessments (all of which must be digitally logged and certifiable).

How This Becomes Evidence:  

Every record—of consent, breach notification, DPIA, access audits—becomes vital in investigations or court proceedings. If certified under Evidence Law (more below), these records could become conclusive or even determinative legal evidence.

D. Corporate, Tax & MSME Laws: Digital Data as Legal Artifact

### Companies Act, 2013

- Section 2(12) & 2(36): "Books and papers" and "documents" definition now includes all digital formats.

- Rule 27, Companies (Management and Administration) Rules, 2014: Mandates digital records to be accessible, retrievable, complete, and secure in India.

- Effect: Electronic minutes, board resolutions, filings—when certified and produced as per rules—are now direct evidence in company law proceedings.

### Income Tax Act, 1961

- Section 132: Empowers search and seizure of not just physical but also digital records.

- Proposed updates for 2025: Enables authorities to bypass passwords, inspect emails, cloud files, and encrypted chats when investigating tax issues.

### MSMED Act, 2006

- Udyam Registration and Digital Data: Relies on fully digital records (investment, turnover, GST returns), providing easily auditable evidence in disputes, especially regarding MSME status.

E. The Global Trend: EU AI Act and Cross-Border Implications

- EU AI Act: Mandates strict log-keeping, transparency, and auditability for high-risk AI systems.

- AI Liability Directive Proposal: Makes it easier for plaintiffs to prove harm by shifting some evidentiary burden to those deploying AI.

- Takeaway: Indian firms using AI for contract drafting, HR, or analytics must retain not just outputs, but records of model inputs, training data, and system prompts—to comply with both Indian and (where relevant) EU requirements.

F. The New Evidence Regime: BSA, BNSS, BNS

### Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA)—The New Evidence Act

- Section 61: Affirms admissibility of electronic/digital records—no longer dismissed because they are not paper.

- Section 63(1)-(4): Specifies that computer output is a "document" if:

  - Produced from a device regularly used for that activity,

  - Device was operating properly,

  - Output is a regular product of business,

  - Accompanied by a certificate specifying particulars, including device, process, hash value, and compliance.

- Section 93: Presumption of authenticity for electronic records more than five years old, kept in proper custody unless disproven.

### Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS)—Criminal Procedure

- Section 2(a), 2(i): Broadly define "audio-video electronic means" and "electronic communication" to cover almost all modern forms of digital communication.

- Section 105: Mandates that all search and seizure procedures—right from the entry to the detailed list—must be recorded on audio-video, which is then sent to the Magistrate. This preserves chain of custody and procedural integrity.

### Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS)—Penal Code

- Section 241: Destruction of electronic record to prevent its availability in evidence is now a punishable offence (mirroring but expanding IPC Section 201).

- Sections 61 & 63: Evidence-admissibility provisions, paralleling those in BSA for electronic records in criminal context.

G. How These Statutes Interact: Making Digital Footprints Admissible

H. Strategic, Practical Recommendations for Business Leaders and Lawyers

1. Forensic-Ready Infrastructure

• Design systems to automatically log, encrypt, and timestamp all digital activities: user consents, audit trails, board minutes, contract logs.

• Integrate functions to immediately generate BSA/S. 65B-compliant certificates at the point of data creation for easy court submission.

2.      Privacy and Consent Automation

• Use dynamic dashboards for consent management, instant withdrawal, and automated erasure.

• Keep system logs of all consent flows—not just for DPDP compliance but to serve as potential legal evidence.

3.      Proactive Compliance Audits

• Map digital information flows: identify all business-critical repositories (inboxes, WhatsApp, CRMs, cloud), and periodically test for retrieval and certification compliance.

• Cross-verify BSA, IT Act, and GDPR/EU AI Act requirements.

4.      Legal-IT Team Collaboration

• Delegate Data Protection Officer and digital evidence custodian roles.

• Run periodic workshops on chain of custody, log certification, BNSS/BNS protocols.

5.       Prevent Destruction and Spoliation

• Institute retention policies and automated alerts for attempted deletion/modification of critical digital records.

• Audit logs for destruction to ensure compliance with BNS Section 241.

6.      AI System Logs

• Retain versioning, input/output logs, prompts, and training data archives for all AI systems affecting legal/business processes, anticipating demands from courts or regulators (both in India and EU).

7.        Prepare for Cross-Border Litigation

• If engaging with EU/US partners/customers, harmonize evidence management for international standards, especially on AI and digital data (EU AI Act, GDPR, etc.).

I. Thought-Provoking Questions for Leaders and Legal Teams

• Can your organization produce, within hours, a BSA-compliant certificate for every key digital contract, board decision, or consent log?

• If a competitor or regulator initiates proceedings, are you able to produce audio-video search logs, DPDP consent forms, and integrity-verified backups without risk of challenge?

• Could an inadvertent deletion of a server file expose the company or its officers to criminal liability under BNS Section 241?

• Are your AI services and contract platforms logging data in a manner compliant not only for privacy but to stand as future evidence?

J. Conclusion: Digital Governance as Corporate Defense

The new Indian regime—spanning data privacy, evidence, criminal and civil procedure, taxation, and even AI—means that every byte counts. For businesses, this is the time to transform compliance architecture from tick-box exercise to core corporate defense.

In 2025 and beyond, success will belong to those who not only respect and protect personal data, but who also build forensic-grade, certifiable, and litigation-ready digital footprints. The future is already here: your digital trail is your strongest legal asset, or your greatest vulnerability.

By integrating the DPDP Act, IT Act, Companies Act, Income Tax Act, MSMED Act, EU AI Act, BSA, BNSS, and BNS into robust digital evidence management, Indian enterprises and legal professionals can unlock both regulatory compliance and strategic advantage in litigation and business disputes.

Visit Us- https://www.dcorpo.legal/